Monday, January 30, 2012
Felice Beato's Japan
Source
I feel as if Felice Beato tried to capture a Japanese sort of essence in this photo, while also making it relateable to a western viewing audience by including the myth of a band of musicians.
The musicians here are very plainly dressed in Japanese style clothing, and also sport very Japanese hairdos. Their instruments also appear foreign, and differ from the style of instruments used by western street performers, creating a feeling of what is Japanese to a westerner. At the same time, their instruments are also recognizable enough so that westerners may have been able to guess at what they sounded like, contributing to the street performer myth.
Together, I think these components make this image very marketable to a western audience. The Japanese feeling derived from the way of dress, and foreign instruments combined with the common myth of street performers allows for an image of Japanese life to be painted in the eyes of a westerner. By building upon the base of the street performer myth, they can create something that is familiar and yet foreign, simultaneously allowing them to make their own inferences about Japanese life and see it in a way that is pleasing to them. Together with the description to the left of the photo, viewers are able to paint an exotic picture of Japan while incorporating their own views.
Source
This image seems to work to capture the grandeur of Japan's architecture and the pristine feeling of the greenery around it. The foreign design style along with the beauty of the land helps to add to the Westerner's sense of Japan's mystery, and foreign, but intriguing looking architecture.
The buildings featured in the picture are on a grander scale, giving them a sense of importance, greatness, and longevity. The stairs leading away to the buildings enhance this effect, as do the tall trees lining the outskirts of the buildings. Together with a foreign style of construction, these factors would build on Westerner's interest in Japan and its perceived nature of being different, and by relation, somewhat mysterious. The people included within the photo are also dressed in a Japanese style, further adding to the 'foreign' feeling of the photo and appealing to western taste and intrigue.
The text included with this photo is also interesting, as it contrasts with the serene scene, but yet also appeals to western interests in their differences with Japan, such as how justice is delivered. The death of a large number of individuals by beheading would be even more so shocking to a westerner, adding to the perceived foreign nature of Japan, and the picture's worth to the photographer.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
hey, first off I think you analyzed the picture with buildings/stairs really well. I definitely have trouble looking really deeply into architecture and scenery photographs. I was wondering if you thought any of the black man in the musician image though. I understand that Beato may have been appealing to Westerners by putting them in Japanese clothing/make-up but then why do you think he put a black man in the photo as well? Any thoughts?
ReplyDeleteAw, thank you, glad you think so. Also, with the second image, I do think the man is Japanese, but appears to be more tanned, probably due to the contrast of the image as well. This was also probably a ploy by the photographer though, as the same connotations would apply to this man, again giving a feeling that the Japanese aren't as superior.
DeleteAbout the first image, I like your comparison to a band of musicians which were familiar to westerners. I also think that this photo attracted western people, because they do the same activity with different clothes and instruments.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your opinion on the second image, and I found it interesting to see both Japanese-style and western-style people in this picture.
Thank you for the comment! Also, yes, I thought it was interesting as well, especially since it is Beato's collection.
Delete